Denny Emerson: Racing’s mixed emotions

Multiple stakes winners Silver Comet, by Flip Sal and Loyal Pal, by Caro. Photo courtesy Horse Collaborative

Multiple stakes winners Silver Comet, by Flip Sal and Loyal Pal, by Caro. Photo courtesy Horse Collaborative

BY DENNY EMERSON —I am well aware that many people have mixed emotions about horse racing. The industry has a reputation for pushing too many young horses too hard at too young an age, with too many getting injured in the process, and that’s a valid criticism.

I also believe, though, that modern sport horses in general, most of which are at least part thoroughbred, would be LESS tough and hardy and athletic WITHOUT racing being used as a tough filtering system to find out which horses can handle all the athletic stresses, because the winners tend to breed on, and the losers don’t.

I’ve stood lots of former racehorses as stallions and I’ve ridden dozens of thoroughbreds, and I happen to think there is a strong correlation between racing class and general athletic class.

I just read a piece about how the “dirty little secret” of modern thoroughbred breeding is “fragile ankles,” horses being bred for speed with little consideration being given to genetically proven soundness in the bloodlines.

Thoroughbreds in morning work. Photo by and courtesy of Horse Collaborative

Thoroughbreds in morning work. Photo by and courtesy of Horse Collaborative

And maybe some of that is true, but it’s far from the whole story.

Morgans and Arabians don’t have huge bone, yet some of these little horses can pull off huge feats of endurance, but what underlies this is literally YEARS of slow, incrementally increasing work. Something the racing thoroughbreds, regardless of pedigree CAN’T have if they race at two and three, because they literally haven’t lived for enough years.

Fitness staves off (doesn’t prevent) the likelihood of injury, and fitness takes more time than the flat racing industry generally allows.

If there IS a “dirty little secret” in the racing industry, I would think it’s too fast too early, without building in the years of needed slow work, but THAT really isn’t a secret. People have been saying that forever.

So, whatever the breed, whatever the use, first get them fit. THEN ask the harder questions. Don’t hope to get them fit as you push them to run or jump or slide or spin or compress and lift or collect. That approach is backwards, and it will so often backfire on you, and all you will wind up with is another hurt or demoralized horse.

Big time stakes winner O’Hara, by Ballymoss. Loaned to us back in the 1970s by Thornmar Farm. Photo courtesy Horse Collaborative

Big time stakes winner O’Hara, by Ballymoss. Loaned to us back in the 1970s by Thornmar Farm. Photo courtesy Horse Collaborative

The REAL “dirty little secret” (and not just in racing) is ignorant or impatient humans.

So for me, racing is that old saying, “a mixed bag,” lots of good, but plenty also that needs to be fixed.

Can horses have long racing careers and come off the track sound and sane? You bet. I have several at our farm right now. Can racing break some down? You bet. So it’s not an easy call.

About the Author
Named “One of the 50 most influential horsemen of the Twentieth Century” by The Chronicle of the Horse, Denny Emerson was elected to the USEA Hall of Fame in 2005. He is the only rider to have ever won both a gold medal in Eventing and a Tevis Buckle in endurance. He is a graduate of Dartmouth College and author of How Good Riders Get Good, and continues to ride and train from his Tamarack Hill Farm in Vermont and Southern Pines, NC.

About Horse Collaborative: The Horse Collaborative is a new platform for horse people to connect and share with friends. Since launching in 2012, the Horse Collaborative has quickly cultivated and connected a passionate international community of horse lovers, athletes, equine professionals, hobbyists, dreamers, and people who just think horses are cute.

— Photo and story reprinted by Off Track Thoroughbreds with permission of Denny Emerson and the Horse Collaborative.

Photo of the Week: King of his domain

Isa My Love retired to sunny New Mexico with former law enforcement officers Bruce and Sandy Carr.

Isa My Love retired to sunny New Mexico with former law enforcement officers Bruce and Sandy Carr.

Four years ago, Sandy and Bruce Carr “fled the rains” of Seattle, and the pressures of dual law enforcement careers, to retire on a small, sun-drenched ranch in New Mexico.

And shortly thereafter, another retiree completed the picture.

Isa My Love, nicknamed Easy, had been retired to Texas horse charity LoneStar Outreach to Place Ex-Racers (LOPE) with small bone chips in his legs when the Carr family happened upon him while on holiday. While visiting their daughter in Austin, Sandy Carr decided to plug in the phrase “off-track Thoroughbred” into an online search, and up popped the charity, and her future horse.

Prior to this quest, Carr had been on many paths in horse sport. Those included carriage driving and owning shares in racehorses at Emerald Downs, she says. But for a long time, she knew her next chapter would include an OTTB.

Isa My Love
Sire: Istan
Dam: Affirmable, by Affirmed
Foal date: March 28, 2009
“I started reading your blog, so you’re part of the problem. I read it for almost a year, and I was thinking, oh-my-gosh, if I ever got another animal here to feed, I want to get an off-track Thoroughbred,” she says. “I was just getting ready to adopt a gelding who had brought in hundreds of thousands of dollars (in earnings), when the owners decided to keep him. We were going to my daughter’s house in Austin for Christmas, and so I just literally Googled off-track Thoroughbreds adoptions Texas” — and there he was, a beautiful, proud gelding with a high shine to his coat.

For the holiday, Carr’s husband put a $1 bill in her stocking, the amount LOPE charged them to take Easy to his new home in New Mexico.

“Easy had slight bone chips in his front legs, above the fetlock, and not affecting the joints. The Austin Equine Hospital ran all his X-rays and said he’d be fine for walk/trot and trail riding,” she says.

In this photo, Easy had just arrived at the ranch, and Sandy Carr was ready with her Nikon camera.

“I just happened to snap that picture after he arrived from Texas, where it was really warm, to rough-around-the-edges New Mexico,” she says. “The light is always perfect here, and he just looked so beautiful, with the juniper in the background, it looks like he’s surveying his kingdom.”

80+ horses rescued from Va. death farm

This white Appaloosa was one of the horses at Peaceable Farms in Virginia who was euthanized following a raid on Oct. 20 by the County sheriff and attorney.

This white Appaloosa was one of the horses at Peaceable Farms in Virginia who was euthanized following a raid on Oct. 20 by the County sheriff and attorney.

At first there was only darkness and the putrid stench of death.

Then the flashlights were switched on and narrow beams of light revealed the dead, near-dead and terrified horses of Peaceable Farms, in a scene described in media reports as “the most horrendous” scene of animal abuse.

“We’d shine a flashlight in a stall and there’d be walking skeletons staring back,” says Miah Proulx of Hope’s Legacy Equine Rescue. “There was one horse” who was terrified “and he was lunging over the stall walls trying to bite people as we walked horses onto a big, open-air stock trailer.

“But as soon as (the rearing horse) saw the trailer and realized he was leaving, his whole personality changed. He was such a cool guy and he walked right on. Unfortunately, he was beyond hope, and he had to be euthanized after his rescue. He was a 17-hand Saddlebred named Carl Meyers.”

Proulx worked alongside several other horse rescues, whose operators lined up with trucks and trailers to remove approximately 80 horses during a raid on the 501 c 3 nonprofit horse charity led by the Orange County Sheriff’s Office Oct. 20. The owner of the farm, Anne Goland, has been charged with 27 counts of misdemeanor animal cruelty, according to the Washington Post, and was being held without bail.

As prosecutors prepared their case, five rescue organizations worked tirelessly to triage endangered animals, focusing their attention on the living, doing their best to ignore the carnage. Rescue organizations were: Hope’s Legacy Equine Rescue, Central Virginia Horse Rescue, Traveller’s Rest Equine Elders Sanctuary, New Beginnings Horse Rescue, and Gentle Giants Draft Horse Rescue.

This chestnut Saddlebred named Gentleman is 18. Since his rescue, he is doing well and gaining weight.

This chestnut Saddlebred named Gentleman is 18. Since his rescue, he is doing well and gaining weight.

There was no time to give in to tears. Horses were in immediate danger of dying; one died in the night, and another after he was rescued, Proulx says.

“When I got to the property the bodies of dead horses were being loaded into a dumpster,” Proulx says. “One Thoroughbred died on his own. We don’t know who he was. He had an illegible tattoo, and was estimated to be in his late 20s. His body condition was appalling, and he had a heart murmur.”

She adds, “Horses were tagged with red, yellow or green tags, depending on how critical they were. The red-tagged ones had the most critical need to get off the property because there was a chance they wouldn’t survive the night. We were able to take seven red-tagged horses, but sadly there was one out in a field, and we couldn’t find him. He did wind up going down during the night, and he had to be euthanized the following morning.”

Working madly, wildly, but with fanatical purpose, Proulx took 29 horses.

Cindy Smith, of Central Virginia Horse Rescue, took 10 total equines, including mules, a Saddlebred, an Appaloosa, two Thoroughbreds, two miniature donkeys and two young mules.

The scene, she says, “Was like a bad circus.”

A Thoroughbred ex-racehorse identified as Mattapexplantation was rescued, and is recovering at Central Virginia Horse Rescue.

A Thoroughbred ex-racehorse identified as Mattapexplantation was rescued, and is recovering at Central Virginia Horse Rescue.

“We got the call on the 19th to be ready to move the next morning, because the sheriff and county attorney would be seizing the horses,” she says. “We were there by 10 the next morning (Oct. 20), and there were approximately seven other trailers on the scene at that time. Once the vets were all ready, and everything got moving, it was pretty organized.”

As the media filmed and reported the sting, trailers and trucks, pulled up, loaded horses and other animals, and pulled away. And in this way, nearly 100 animals were loaded up and transported to safety, Smith says.

“Was I shocked at the number of dead and starving animals? Yes. It’s almost like having PTSD; you go in and it affects you on such a visceral level,” Smith says. “But in rescue, we’re also lucky, because we feel like we’re doing something.”

And as they placed their hands on the needy horses, many more hands across Virginia and other states dug deep to support their effort.

As if they were airdropping food to prisoners of war, people and organizations came out of the woodwork to send food, money, blankets and supplies.

“The community support has just been amazing,” Proulx says. “Donations, both financial, and with equipment have been so tremendous I’m literally swimming in horse blankets. We’ve had volunteers come out to clean stalls, brush manes and monitor water levels.”

Donations keep rolling in. Here is a recent pile that accumulated at Hope's Legacy while Proulx stepped away from the farm.

Donations keep rolling in. Here is a recent pile that accumulated at Hope’s Legacy while Proulx stepped away from the farm.

Rachel Miller, an equine specialist for Southern States feed and gardening store, organized much of the outpouring.

“My manager and I wanted to make sure that when the horses were taken off the farm, that they had all the alfalfa and Triple Crown Senior feed they needed. We just wanted to make sure the charities weren’t overburdened,” Miller says. “So I put out a request on Facebook, and it reached over 13,000 people. We were completely unprepared for the number of people who stepped up to help.”

Though the list of donors is too long to mention every business and person who gave, Miller notes that Triple Crown Nutrition donated a half ton of alfalfa the first day, as did Stanley Hay Company. Southern States, as well as the Southern States corporate office, donated Triple Crown Senior feed as well.

Members of the ROTC arrived at Central Virginia Horse Rescue to lend a hand.

Members of the ROTC arrived at Central Virginia Horse Rescue to lend a hand.

“Our customers and others in the community purchased feed and 74 bales of alfalfa hay. I’ve got customers who have donated round bales from their own supplies; one’s taking 11 round bales out to the charities, another took 50 round bales from their own storage to donate,” she says. “I even have a customer who has offered up to 50 bales, and to take them out, as needed, over the winter to support the horses.”

Donors have also purchased blankets, and Dover Saddlery stepped up to absorb shipping costs. Dover also donated blankets. Zoetis, an equine vaccine company, donated two cases of dewormer, and Farm Vet donated ample supplies of the costly drug, UlcerGard.

“We’ve had so many companies step up to help. The owner of Mad Tack, a small tack shop and local business, spent one day with his truck and trailer helping to pull those horses out of there, and he used his shop as a donation/storage spot,” she says. “This has hit everyone in our community. We’ve all seen rescue animals before, but the sheer numbers of thin, starving horses in horse country, that’s what I think we’re reacting to.

“This is an area where we pride ourselves on our horses,” Miller adds. “And the fact that this was a facility that was set up as a rescue, that’s what really got a lot of people. It was a place where horses were supposed to be getting helped. Instead they were dying.”

To read more on the charges against the property owner, please visit this link: http://www.nbc29.com/story/30349381/update-peaceable-farm-owner-charged-with-animal-cruelty