Off Track Thoroughbreds

Balmy Beach and Robin Hannah-Carlton, who was so committed she would have done so at the expense of ever having another one.

An OTTB who was never supposed to walk again has returned to the Canadian showing circuit at age 19, a miracle on four legs with the drive to win.

Balmy Beach, who suffered an acute and mysterious spinal cord virus early in his post-racing career and spent weeks suspended in a sling, recently navigated surefootedly, if not amazingly, around tight corners in the pouring rain at a Canadian horse show. And soon, he and 12-year-old rider Ellah Dubeau-Kielty will tackle the A circuit as though nothing had happened to the gelding; once so sick his case was considered hopeless.

It was on a late September morning in 2004, two weeks after winning the championship at the Canadian National Exhibition, when Balmy Beach went down in his stall. Like a sudden storm that blackens a blue sky, his sickness came on strong, out of nowhere, recalls longtime owner Marilyn Lee of Sherwood Farms, Ontario.

“It was a Sunday morning and we noticed he started making odd noises, and then he started favoring his hind leg. In the span of an hour, he’d collapsed,” Lee says. “By noontime he was thrashing on the ground so badly that his legs were up against the walls … and the local vet said I had two choices: either put him down right there, or drive him 90 minutes to the Ontario Veterinarian College.”

Balmy Beach
Show name: Finders Keepers
Sire: Clever Trick
Dam: Delightful Year, by Half a Year
Foal date: April 27, 1996Unable to end the life of her daughter Robin Hannah-Carlton’s first horse, she quickly organized a team of men and veterinary professionals. At the time, Hannah-Carlton was so intent on saving her first horse that she said, “If the cost of caring for him means I never have another horse, so be it. And, even if he can never be ridden, he’s still my horse.”

And with that mother-daughter commitment, Balmy Beach was sedated and pulled to his feet. And with people holding him from all sides, he was supported on his walk onto the trailer, and for the entirety of the interminable trailer ride.

And they almost made it. But just before they pulled into the hospital parking lot, Balmy went down again.

“To get him off the trailer the hospital we had to administer general anesthesia, drag him out onto the tarp, and once they got him inside, they hoisted him in a sling, suspending him from the ceiling,” she says.

Balmy Beach, a.k.a Finders Keepers, survived a mystery illness to make a miraculous return to the show ring. A Rachel Sulman Photography photo

For two weeks he hung there, enduring test after test after test. West Nile was ruled out, as were equine herpes and rabies. “They couldn’t find a thing, it was really a mystery. They finally called it acute severe spinal cord injury with tetra paresis,” she says. “The doctors told me, in their words, that only a miracle would bring this horse back to return to athletic performance.”

Though his legs were compromised, Balmy Beach maintained a bright disposition and a hearty appetite. So Lee took him home when he was stable enough to transport and left him to graze and bask in her fields. Let’s just say he was a beautiful pasture ornament.

Then something happened. Around 2009, Balmy Beach started looking really good in his field. He was steady on his feet and she’d often marvel at his fluid beauty as he romped in his pasture. “At some point we decided to saddle him back up again and try again,” she says. “This horse loves, loves, loves to jump, and pretty soon he was so good that we sent him back into the show ring.”

In his showing circuit in Ontario, Balmy Beach’s story precedes him. And he’s is a bit of a celebrity, says Lee, who adds that the Thoroughbred who needed a miracle got it and has now returned to the stage for his second act.

“Seeing Ella ride him reminds me of what Robin looked like when she was only 17 and riding this same horse. He’s lightning fast, often beating other horses by a full eight seconds, and I think it’s just incredible that at age 19, a horse who was expected to never walk again is returning to the A Circuit.”

As Balmy Beach romped through a rainy course one recent day, Hannah-Carlton watched her old friend with a lump in her throat. “He is a war horse. He has done more for me in his life than he will ever know,” she says. “And, I can tell he is grateful that I didn’t give up on him when almost everyone told me I should. And seeing him return to the A Circuit is a feeling of pure joy for me.”

Archie’s Echo, 26, raced in the late 90s in New England, and was rescued from New Holland last week by Parx Racing V.P. Sam Elliott and friends.

Wearing battle scars sustained far from the glow of horse-racing’s limelight, an older gelding was saved last week from slaughter by the director of racing for a Pennsylvania racetrack, with key assistance from Thoroughbred advocates, who all mobilized to find a soft landing for the forgotten racehorse.

Suffering an ulcerated eye and missing some flesh on the bone, chestnut ex-racehorse Archie’s Echo, 26, a one-time New England racer at the now-defunct Rockingham Park and Suffolk Downs, was saved from the New Holland kill pen by Sam Elliott of Parx Racing, who pulled out his credit card before he even saw the gelding’s photo.

Archie’s Echo
Sire: Palace Music
Dam: Chic Star
Foal date: May 8, 1989Handing the card to Danielle Montgomery of the Parx retirement charity Turning for Home, he said simply, “Pull him.”

And with that directive, and the final go-ahead from her superior, Michael Ballezzi, Montgomery set about saving the old timer from a fate no horse deserves, and securing a layup facility where the T’bred could receive medical attention to address his eye, weight loss, and any other ailments. “His eye is ulcerated and he is blind from some sort of former trauma,” Montgomery says, noting that he was referred to as the “one-eyed horse” when she went to pull him.

As the transaction was completed, and Archie’s Echo was put on a path to freedom, Elliott and some old friends from the New England racing circuit pulled together for the old horse.

Lorita Lindemann, a longtime race trainer and Thoroughbred advocate who, back in the day, worked closely with Elliott on Suffolk Downs’s zero-slaughter racetrack policy, took one look at the old chestnut and immediately recognized one of the first horses she ever groomed when she was just a kid herself, working her first racetrack job at Rockingham Park.

A win photo showing Archie’s Echo in his New England racing days.

“After Danielle texted me Archie’s picture and I saw the chestnut with white blaze, I remembered him right away, and got goosebumps all up and down my arms,” Lindemann says. “I told her, ‘I used to rub that horse!’ He was one of the first horses I ever rubbed, when I was first starting out at Rockingham. Whether you’re grooming or training, you never forget a horse, and when I saw a picture of him at New Holland, I told her to walk into Sam Elliott’s office and show him.

“I’ve known Sam since I was 10 years old. I knew he’d pull the horse.”

And after the first steps of the effort to save Archie was underway, Lindemann and Elliott turned to a third New England connection, a man who turned his passion for horses into the world-renowned Thoroughbred charity: Old Friends.

Michael Blowen, upon hearing the sad story told by his longtime friends, readily agreed to give a permanent retirement home to the old gentleman.

After Archie’s Echo clears quarantine at a New Jersey layup farm and is deemed fit to travel, he will be loaded into a trailer and taken to his new home to live alongside horseracing greats Game On Dude, winner of 14 graded stakes, and Silver Charm, winner of the 1997 Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes.

Both superstars were retired to Old Friends by Triple Crown winning trainer Bob Baffert. After Baffert-trained racehorse American Pharoah won the crown jewels of racing in the 147th running of the Belmont Stakes June 6, he donated $50,000 to Old Friends. That funding, says Blowen, made it possible to give a home to Archie’s Echo.

“We just got our check from Mr. Baffert, so we have a little breathing room,” Blowen says. “So when Lorita called to tell me about Archie’s Echo, and though I didn’t remember what he looked like, I remembered his name, and that he used to run night races at Rockingham Park. I said we would take him as soon as he’s fit to travel.”

So instead of taking the long ride to the slaughterhouse, Archie’s Echo, now a little careworn and missing an eye, will live with Game On Dude and Silver Charm. All thanks to some old friends from the New England circuit.